Shooting at Poway Synagogue Underscores Link Between Internet Radicalization and Violence
A shooting in a California synagogue in which police say a 19-year-old man killed one and injured three others underscores a link between online radicalization of white supremacists and terroristic violence.
Police identified the attacker as John T. Earnest, who they said entered the Chabad of Poway synagogue in Poway, California, during Passover celebrations Saturday and opened fire using an AR-15. Chabad member Lori Gilbert Kaye, 60, died from injuries. Three others were injured in the shooting.
Earnest hails from the San Diego neighborhood of Rancho Pe帽asquitos, according to聽.
Before the attack, Earnest posted what he described as an 鈥渙pen letter鈥 on the white supremacist-friendly forum 8chan, . The man accused of murdering 50 Muslim worshippers in Christchurch, New Zealand,聽in March also uploaded a statement before the shootings. And like the alleged New Zealand terrorist, Earnest鈥檚 statement was steeped in white supremacist tropes and inside jokes commonly shared in their online communities, based upon Hatewatch鈥檚 analysis of the document. Earnest鈥檚 statement also included the hallmarks common among radicalized white supremacists, such as adulation of suspected or convicted mass murderers and propagation of the false claims of a global plan to replace white people.
For example, Earnest praised the carnage in Christchurch, New Zealand, in his statement, citing that live-streamed act of violence as an influence on his own attack. He mentioned the name of the accused terrorist 10聽different times in his statement.
鈥淸The New Zealand attacker] was a catalyst for me,鈥 he wrote of the attack that killed 50 people in two mosques. 鈥淗e showed me that it could be done. It needed to be done.鈥
Earnest also referenced Robert Bowers in his statement. Bowers is the man accused of killing 11 Jewish people in a terror attack on Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in October 2018. Bowers similarly possessed an intimate connection to the world of online radicalization. He posted a brief message to other white supremacists on the fringe social media website Gab on the same morning he allegedly opened fire in the synagogue.
鈥淕enocide of the European race鈥
White supremacists commonly blame Jewish people for what they call 鈥渨hite genocide,鈥 a false and pervasive conspiracy theory suggesting white people are deliberately and systematically being replaced by other races. Earnest appeared to address this trope in his personal statement by claiming that Jews are responsible for a 鈥渕eticulously planned genocide of the European race.鈥
The men arrested for carrying out the terror attacks in Pittsburgh and Christchurch espoused that same conspiracy theory.
Beyond fringe online platforms like 8chan, Gab and, the similar but more high-traffic forum, 4chan, the ideas behind the 鈥渨hite genocide鈥 conspiracy theory are promoted by pundits with hundreds of thousands of followers on Twitter, such as Stefan Molyneux and Lauren Southern. It鈥檚 also promoted by high-traffic white supremacist websites of the 鈥渁lt-right鈥 movement like 鈥 The Daily Stormer,鈥 鈥淕oy Talk,鈥 and 鈥 The Right Stuff鈥 podcast network.
But the false claim isn鈥檛 limited to the fringe. Fox News鈥 commentator Tucker Carlson warned viewers during his program, 鈥淭ucker Carlson Tonight,鈥 in October 2018 that a college professor from Georgetown was聽 of white men. Carlson鈥檚 show, which frequently depicts聽, reaches more than聽, according to Nielsen ratings taken in March 2019.
A pattern of lionizing killers and accused killers
Earnest鈥檚 professed admiration for the alleged Christchurch killer and Bowers follows a growing trend in far-right extremist propaganda of lionizing murderers, terrorists or people accused of committing those crimes who promote white supremacist beliefs.
For example, white supremacists sometimes share memes depicting as 鈥渟aints鈥 terrorists like Timothy McVeigh, the man who killed 168 people and injured close to 700 more when he bombed the Alfred P. Murrah building in Oklahoma City in 1995; Dylann Roof, the man who murdered nine black churchgoers in Charleston in 2015; and Anders Breivik, the Norwegian terrorist who murdered 77 people in 2011.
The meme creators typically write something like in the text portion of the meme to convey veneration for the mass murderer. More recently, Bowers and the alleged Christchurch terrorist have received similar meme treatment by white supremacists. The "saint" meme first gained popularity in another violent internet subculture聽鈥 involuntary celibates聽or "incels." The moniker has been applied to killers incels believe were acting on behalf of their cause. Some incels refer to聽Elliot Rodger, who killed six and injured 14 in Isla Vista, California in 2014, as their "patron saint."聽
A week before the attack in San Diego, a Twitter user with more than 2,000 followers going by the handle @EvilHonkler used such language. That Twitter user wrote, 鈥淪aint Breivik was a LARPing WigNat until he wasn鈥檛.鈥
LARPing, or live action role play, connotes the idea that someone is pretending to be someone they aren鈥檛. Wignat is derogatory slang used by some white supremacists to mock working-class white men for bringing embarrassment to the movement. The statement suggests that any white supremacist can go from merely posting online anonymously to carrying out a terror attack in real life.
鈥淪aint [Dylann] Roof was a LARPing WigNat until he wasn鈥檛,鈥 @EvilHonkler also wrote in . 鈥淪aint McVeigh was a LARPing WigNat until he wasn鈥檛.鈥
Twitter suspended the @EvilHonkler account Saturday.
After the Poway attack, Andrew 鈥淲eev鈥 Auernheimer, who writes for and provides technical support to The Daily Stormer, wrote Saturday in a private forum for that website that white supremacists should build monuments to men like Earnest.
鈥淭hey鈥檙e all getting statues,鈥 聽of men who commit or are accused of committing acts of terror in the name of a white supremacist ideology. 鈥淚t鈥檚 definitely the wrong thing, but they鈥檙e all still heroes. Fools, but still heroes and martyrs.鈥
Incidents of arson and suspected arson
Earnest boasted in his public statement about setting fire to a mosque in Escondido, California, without getting caught by police. The Islamic Center of Escondido, which is close to San Diego, was set on fire on March 24, according to police, who are investigating the incident as聽.
鈥淸Police] didn鈥檛 report the message I spray-painted on the parking lot,鈥 Earnest wrote. 鈥淚 wrote 鈥楩or [the accused New Zealand terrorist] -t. /pol/鈥).鈥
The abbreviation 鈥/pol/鈥 refers to subsections of both 8chan and 4chan where white supremacists often congregate and share memes linked to the internet radicalization of white supremacists.
Arson attempts on mosques, like the one in Escondido, have occurred elsewhere in the U.S. in 2019. For example, a man聽, Texas, on April 23.
Earnest鈥檚 boast of leaving behind graffiti at the scene of a place where he attempted to commit arson bears a striking similarity to an incident that聽happened in Tennessee in March of 2019. There, someone left behind a white supremacist symbol in the immediate vicinity of a building owned by the Highlander Education and Research Center that was burned down, according to a statement made by that civil rights organization.
Police have not designated the Highlander Center fire as arson but were investigating the blaze along with the local Fire Marshall鈥檚 office earlier this month. The Highlander Center once hosted civil rights icons like Martin Luther King Jr. and Rosa Parks.
The d茅j脿 vu sensation of online radicalization
Analysts at the Southern Poverty Law Center assert that while white supremacists may not always convene in a physical space, they are convening on websites and internet subcultures where they regularly plan and promote violence 鈥 activity that has repeatedly manifested in a physical space.
Others who monitor these online extremist spaces agree. The New York Times tech columnist Kevin Roose聽聽while speaking about the New Zealand attack on the podcast 鈥淭he Daily,鈥 鈥淚 think we鈥檙e still coming to terms with the fact that there鈥檚 this pipeline of extremism, and we know how it runs and we know where it happens. We know who is involved, and we know that sometimes it has these devastating, tragic consequences.鈥
Earnest referenced the feelings of familiarity around this type of attack in his statement, writing of those who report on extremists, 鈥淢ake sure to call me a 鈥榳hite supremacist鈥 and 鈥榓nti-semite鈥 鈥 [those words have] lost all their meaning.鈥
Photo by Sandy Huffaker/Getty Images/AFP
Editor's Note: New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern聽not to use the name of the alleged Christchurch terrorist in the aftermath of that attack, which is why Hatewatch omitted that man鈥檚 name. Hatewatch typically uses the names of terrorists and accused terrorists because our publication specializes in providing intelligence about extremists who commit acts of terror, like the murder in Christchurch.